Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed


  • Advertise on RightMichigan.com


    NEWS TIPS!

    Get the RightMighigan.com toolbar!


    RightMichigan.com

    Buzz

    Who are the NERD fund donors Mr Snyder?

    Raise the curtain.

    Grassroots Pro-Lifers Must Strongly Oppose the Expansion of Embryonic Stem Cell Research in MI


    By Andrew Shirvell, Section News
    Posted on Thu Oct 11, 2007 at 12:29:25 AM EST
    Tags: (all tags)

    This month, the Michigan Catholic Conference (MCC) and Right to Life of Michigan (RTL of MI) have begun a massive state-wide informational campaign in order to educate their respective supporters concerning their moral opposition to the expansion of embryonic stem cell research in Michigan.

    The in-house educational campaign is seen as a precursor to what will take place in the larger public arena if and when, as expected, a pro-embryonic stem cell research petition initiative develops in the coming months and places the issue squarely before Michigan voters in November 2008.  

    The MCC and RTL of MI are correct to start with educating and motivating their own membership on this crucial moral issue, which has many political implications.

    The truth is that many pro-life politicos have been far from faithful in opposing the destruction of human embryos for research purposes.  Moreover, misleading polling questions give the impression that there is a huge amount of public support for embryonic research/experimentation (unlike for abortion on demand, for instance, since polling shows that a majority of Americans consistently remain "uncomfortable" about that issue).  This deceptive impression of citizen support for embryonic stem cell research in turn leads otherwise pro-life politicians to support such research, or, more often, to sit on the sidelines of the debate.  Hence, a vicious circle ensues, which inherently benefits proponents of embryonic stem cell research.

    RTL of MI and the MCC's educational campaign on embryonic (versus adult) stem cell research is a good start in attempting to unify grassroots pro-lifers within the state on this crucial issue.  Unifying and motivating Michigan pro-lifers will electrify the core base of the Michigan Republican Party, and the Michigan conservative movement in general, since the base of each of those two entities is strongly pro-life.  This electrification of the base will in turn spur Michigan pro-life politicians to jump in on the right side of the debate over expanding embryonic stem cell research when such a discussion really gets going in the summer and fall of 2008, if indeed a pro-embryonic stem cell research ballot question is placed before Michigan voters.

    Yet, there is one major problem that the stem cell debate inherently causes for those trying to rally the troops against embryonic stem cell research, which is that it tends to be much, much less of an emotionally-charged issue for people, and pro-lifers in particular, than say abortion or saving Terri Schiavo, for example.  

    As a true believing pro-lifer, I know in my heart that opposing embryonic stem cell research is just as important as opposing the daily slaughter that takes place in the abortion mills, since tiny, microscopic embryos in a Petri dish are just as much human beings as those unborn children with heartbeats and brain activity who are further developed and live in their mothers' wombs.  

    But it is true that, if given a choice, I will probably spend a greater amount of my time advocating against abortion than against embryonic stem cell research.  I suspect that many of my fellow Michigan pro-lifers would agree with me.  

    Nevertheless, I think the leadership of RTL of MI and the MCC can motivate the pro-life grassroots to get as passionate about protecting human embryonic life (in a Petri dish) as we have been concerning unborn life in the womb.  In fact, a recent RTL of MI mailing piece from long-time president Barbara Listing identifies who the opposition is and likens it to the arch-enemy of abortion opponents:

    "Universities, various members of the academia, hospitals, health care systems, independent laboratories, researchers of all stripes, and politicians representing both major political parties have formed an unholy alliance hellbent on destroying innocent human life all in the name of research."      

    . . .

    "This debate is nothing new.  It is as old as time itself.  It's all about lies and deception in pursuit of the almighty dollar!  Come to think of it. . .those are the identical motives behind the abortion industry.  Now, isn't that a coincidence?"

    It sure isn't.  And neither is it a coincidence that RTL of MI's strategy in mobilizing its supporters against the expansion of embryonic stem cell research is, in part, to compare this relatively new fight to the long-time struggle to end the abortion holocaust.  

    Well, I think this strategy can work.  I know that hearing about the evil of embryonic stem cell research at Mass this past Sunday - Respect Life Sunday - as well as reading about it in the parish bulletin and receiving several informational pieces in the mail over the past few days has me more motivated to fight the potential expansion of embryonic stem cell research here in Michigan.  

    This week's column is your evidence for that last assertion.

    P.S. To find out more about adult versus embryonic stem cell research, including what the current Michigan laws are concerning both forms of research, please see:  http://www.stemcellresearchcures.com

    About the author: Andrew Shirvell, Esq., is a pro-life citizen activist who writes a weekly column that is published every Thursday for RightMichigan.com in which he focuses upon Michigan pro-life issues. Shirvell attended Ave Maria School of Law - Ann Arbor, where he served as president of the school's Bioethics Society, from 2004-2005.  He also served as president of Students for Life at the University of Michigan - Ann Arbor, from 2000-2002.

    < Please Dr. Dobson | Portrait of a Tax Hiker: Kate Ebli (D - Frenchtown Township) >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    Thanks (none / 0) (#1)
    by Nick on Thu Oct 11, 2007 at 05:51:29 AM EST
    for picking up the standard and moving forward in the fight, Andrew!

    It goes beyond a life issue... (none / 0) (#2)
    by mikefisk on Thu Oct 11, 2007 at 10:00:02 AM EST
    ...it brings up issues as to why the government needs to step in to fund an area of research that private investors have been running away from, not because of moral qualms, but because it doesn't work.

    Adult stem cell research and treatment has already made massive progress towards alleviating suffering and curing diseases, something which, unless you were either reading scientific literature or alternative media sources, most people probably know nothing about.  All researchers have been able to generate with embryonic stem cells, despite knowing every bit as much about them as they do adult stem cells, is cancer (primarily a class of malignancies called teratomas).  Not to mention adult stem cells have the advantage of being bio-identical with the patient, as you can harvest them from the individual patient's blood or bone marrow... even if embryonic stem cells ever worked, we'd be condemning these people to a life of anti-rejection medication as the body will work feverishly to rid itself of the foreign presence inside of it.

    I'm in a bit of a soft center when it comes to life issues (leaning more toward the pro-life side of things, though), but there are issues with embryonic stem cell research that should give even pro-choice advocates some serious pause...

    "To all those whom I have not yet offended: Please stand by, and I will work to remedy the situation as soon as possible."

    As always, great article... (none / 0) (#3)
    by Bridget on Fri Oct 12, 2007 at 10:02:18 AM EST
    Hello Andrew,

    As always, your article is informative and well intended. Thanks for the information and the interesting avenues of thought on a timely and provocative issue.  We have gotten mailers at our home as well. We also read something this week via the GR Catholic Diocese Magazine as well. They are definately doing the push.

    The biggest challenge RTL and MCL and others will have is getting information out AND then people understanding and getting it.

    The main stream media has brainwashed the masses into being suspicious and hateful about religion and faith, believing Global Warming is the answer to humanity and that the break down in marriage, family, country and GOD is a necessary evil to obtain utopia on earth. The MSN think they have progressed us to this la-la land. The rest of us look in only to see frightening chaos and a loss of reason.

    The main stream media has done an equally good job in getting the masses to believe that ESC are worthless and have no human related characteristics unless they are used in lab experimentation for disease. ESC are simply a batch of cells with no connection to human life as we know it. Thus, they can and should be used for furthering the health for the rest of us. This coincides with millions buying the concept that the world as we know it came from nothing. We are supposed to believe that nothing begits nothing. Same with sperm and egg. Apparently nothing coming together begins nothing. If nothing begits nothing, then get pregnant and see what happens. I assure you that bump in nine months and the birthing process if allowed to progress is more than nothing.

    Of course those who say they are science minded and base everything on documented facts and data,
    seem to toss reason out the window when it comes to ESC. ESC has been nothing but a nightmare of massive tumors, unstoppable growth and human distoritions beyond belief. Yet, the reseachers and donors in this area want the world to think ESC has solved disease already and is the promise land for tomorrow. It has NOT.  This is even before we get to the debate of moral and ethicial issues about the use of these cells.  

    People must get educated and understand that adult stem cells and cord cells show amazing current results and also future promise, without harming existing life.  

    Bottom line, RTL and other groups are going to have to break through the all important glass ceiling on ESC debates. One side de-humanizes both the embryo and fetus or else they can't go forward with the elimination program. They can't believe for a second that an egg and sperm meeting, the development of a combined cell to form life and then an embryo taking off and developing into a fetus could possibly be a human life. Their entire arguments and actions are dependent upon this process remaining clinical, detached and inhuman. To do to the contrary is to admit life and death.  

    I used to be a pro-abortion supporter many years ago. I bought the lines sold that we can't go back to the wire hanger days, women have to have a right to their own reproduction rights, we must reserve abortion for the health of the unborn and mother and that we need it for cases of incest and rape. Now we get the argument that ESC are necessary to save other human lives regardless of the actions taken to get there. It's always a case of: I want it, I'll get it. No matter what it takes to get there. Even if I have to kill something or someone to get what I want and need.

    I know alot of women who had abortions. None were for reasons of health, rape or incest. Sadly, all were done due to being very young, having one night stands or sex with men they barely knew, in relationships not even close to engagement or marriage and getting pregnant at times it was not financially, emotionally or psychologically convenient.  I'm sure there are cases to the contrary, but in my travels I have met none.  None of these women could be persuaded to give birth and give up the child. That would leave the mark of their mistake somewhere in the world even if it was not directly in their life anymore. Thus, both the man and woman decide to eliminate the problem completely and totally once and for all.

    All these women I met regretted their abortions.  But sadly, all say they would do the same thing had they to live over the same circumstance and situation again.

    Thus, the mind set must be changed for both men and women when it comes to the beginnings of life, the creation and use of ESC and the final elimination of an unwanted fetus in abortion. The research must be presented, the argument must be made and the position must be cemented that the cells, the embryo and the unborn child are all REAL and they are HUMAN. To do any less will loose this argument as well.  

    I am now a strong pro-life advocate. I see the other side and understand how wrong I was. ESC is not the answer and neither is the taking of another's life when it comes to abortion. So, work like yours does make a difference. People are swithing sides in this battle for life. Too many of us turn away from our conscience in order to make negative and dark choices in our life when we need to. It takes prompting and strength  to listen and act properly when our conscience reminds us to.

    Hopefully in time, everyone will make the best choices for all involved, not just the most vocal players. It takes reading, research, education and life experience to get all of us there. Some simply arrive earlier than others when it comes to doing the right thing.

    You always do great work. Keep up the good fight.

    Regards,

    Bridget

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search